The technology and cyber situation report for boards and executive management

Block network access without legal basis stopped: consequences for companies

5 November 2026 · Data governance · Technology governance · AI summary · reviewed by Remo Stebler

What this is about

The Federal Court has annulled an order issued by the Vaud Public Prosecutor’s Office that required internet service providers to block websites. The background was criminal proceedings by the Vaud Public Prosecutor’s Office concerning alleged investment fraud on the internet. According to the case, dozens of victims were defrauded of more than CHF 1.7 million through a platform. In judgment 7B_52/2026 of 12 October 2026, the court held that the general provisions on seizure in the Criminal Procedure Code do not provide a sufficient legal basis to oblige internet service providers to block websites.

Why this matters for the board and executive management

Switzerland’s highest court recognises the importance of such measures in combating cybercrime, but views it as the task of the legislature to make the necessary political assessments and establish an appropriate legal basis. The court rejects a standalone regulation. Authorities cannot today force a block based on general criminal procedure provisions. In the revised Telecommunications Act, whose consultation period ended in September 2026, the Federal Council proposes allowing network blocking even on the basis of reasonable suspicion of alleged fraud. The board of directors must be able to rely on the executive management keeping track of this regulatory development and the procedure for handling official orders. This concerns overall management oversight pursuant to Art. 716a OR, particularly for business models with online distribution or own provider infrastructure.

Questions for executive management

  1. Do we have a process to review the legal basis of an official blocking or disclosure order before we implement it?
  2. Are we monitoring progress on the Telecommunications Act revision, which will in future allow network blocking on suspicion of fraud, and have we assessed its significance for our business?